Stillwater Associates Insights

The Mechanics of Canada’s Gaseous CFR Credit Market

|
Jun 18, 2026

Canada’s Clean Fuel Regulations (CFR, SOR/2022-140) create a single compliance credit market, but not all credits in that market are equal. The CFR distinguishes between liquid class and gaseous class compliance credits and limits how much a primary supplier (a producer or importer of fossil-based gasoline and diesel) can use gaseous credits toward its compliance obligation; as such, gaseous credits may trade at a discount to liquid credits. As interest in the CFR grows, so does the importance of understanding how the gaseous credit market works. This article explains three aspects of those mechanics: how gaseous credits are created, how they factor into compliance obligations, and how they relate to major CCS infrastructure such as the Oil Sands Alliance’s Pathways CCS project. Each of these mechanisms is less straightforward than it first appears.

How Gaseous Credits Are Created

The starting point for understanding gaseous credits is the account structure the CFR establishes. Readers looking for broader background on the regulation can start with Stillwater’s Canadian Clean Fuel Regulations 101. Under CFR s. 28, the Minister opens two separate accounts for every registered primary supplier and credit creator: a liquid-fuel-compliance-credit account and a gaseous-fuel-compliance-credit account. Every company gets one of each. Which account a credit lands in depends not on whether the fuel that generated it is physically a gas or a liquid, but on how that fuel is used. Credits in the gaseous account carry a use restriction that liquid credits do not, and that restriction is the regulatory foundation for any price difference between the two classes. Under CFR s. 20, gaseous class credits may be created through three pathways. Where the same activities result in a fuel that directly displaces a liquid class fuel in a vehicle application, those activities may alternatively generate liquid class credits rather than gaseous class credits.

  1. Domestic production of eligible low-carbon-intensity fuel (s. 20(c)). A registered creator may produce in Canada a quantity of low-carbon-intensity gaseous fuel and generate gaseous class credits. Eligible fuels are specified in CFR s. 95 and are limited to biogas, renewable natural gas (RNG), renewable propane, and hydrogen. Conventional natural gas does not qualify. The CFR treats biogas and RNG as distinct fuels within this list. Biogas is the raw gas produced from the decomposition of organic matter, such as agricultural, food, or municipal solid waste, and is typically a mixture of methane, carbon dioxide, and trace contaminants. RNG is biogas that has been upgraded, or purified, to pipeline-quality specifications, removing the carbon dioxide and other impurities so that the resulting gas is interchangeable with conventional natural gas. The two terms are often used interchangeably in casual usage, but the CFR’s eligible fuel list at s. 95 distinguishes them as separate fuel types.
  2. Import of eligible low-carbon-intensity fuel (s. 20(b)). A registered creator may import into Canada a quantity of low-carbon-intensity gaseous fuel and generate gaseous class credits under the same eligibility criteria. Both the domestic production and import pathways are reported quarterly under ECCC’s Compliance Category 2 (CC2) reporting framework.
  3. Co-processing (s. 20(a)). When a renewable feedstock is co-processed with a fossil fuel during liquid fuel refining, the process also produces a renewable gaseous output. Section 20(a) authorizes credit creation from that renewable gaseous fraction, provided the project is recognized under s. 30(d) as producing co-processed low-carbon-intensity fuel and is also recognized as reducing the carbon intensity of a gaseous class fuel. Gaseous credits here are an ancillary output of a project whose primary target is a liquid class fuel.

Put simply: There are only three ways to make gaseous credits – produce a qualifying clean gas in Canada, import one, or capture the renewable gas given off as a byproduct when refining fuel made partly from renewable material. Only a short list of fuels qualifies: biogas, renewable natural gas, renewable propane, and hydrogen. Fossil natural gas does not count.

How Gaseous Credits Factor into Compliance

Even where gaseous credits are generated, their contribution to any single supplier’s compliance obligation is capped. Under CFR s. 15(2), credits held in the gaseous-fuel-compliance-credit account (s. 28(b)) used during the compliance demonstration year may not exceed 10% of the primary supplier’s total reduction requirement. This cap applies both to credits used for normal annual compliance under s. 13(4) and to credits used to reduce a deferred portion under s. 18(1)(b). No matter how many gaseous credits a supplier holds, no more than 10% of its obligation can be met with them.

Section 15 contains two parallel caps that operate on the same principle. Credits generated through contributions to a registered emission-reduction funding program (ERFP) are capped at 10% under s. 15(1), and credits created under a generic quantification method (QM) face the same ceiling under s. 15(3). Each cap is measured independently against the total reduction requirement. A supplier making full use of all three mechanisms could in principle satisfy up to 30% of its compliance obligation through these capped pathways, with the remaining 70% met through unrestricted liquid class credits.

Put simply: There are actually three separate 10% limits – one for gaseous credits, one for paying into an emission-reduction fund, and one for credits from a generic calculation method. Even using all three to the maximum, a company can cover at most 30% of its obligation this way; the other 70% must come from standard liquid credits.

The compliance credit clearance mechanism (CCM) operates differently and should not be grouped with these caps. The CCM is sometimes described as a government-run backstop pool. It is not. Under CFR s. 110(1), the CCM can only distribute credits that participants have voluntarily pledged to offer for transfer. When pledged supply falls short of total demand, CFR s. 112(5) provides for proportional allocation: credits are distributed in proportion to each deficient supplier’s share of the total shortfall. If there are not enough pledged credits to cover aggregate demand, all deficient suppliers are likely to fall short. A supplier that cannot cover its full shortfall through the CCM remains out of compliance for the uncovered portion. The CCM is not subject to a percentage cap.

Put simply: The clearance mechanism is not a government safety net – it can only pass along credits that other companies have voluntarily put up for sale, so if there are not enough to go around, a company that still falls short stays out of compliance.

How Gaseous Credits Relate to CCS Infrastructure

The Oil Sands Alliance carbon capture and storage (CCS) project has attracted attention as a potential source of CFR compliance credits, particularly following Prime Minister Mark Carney’s remarks in British Columbia in May 2026 linking it to the proposed West Coast Oil Pipeline. For participants evaluating the CFR compliance implications of that project, the credit-type question is the starting point.

CCS projects generate liquid class Compliance Category 1 (CC1) credits, not gaseous class credits. Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC) has published two relevant quantification methods under the CFR: one for enhanced oil recovery (EOR) with CO2 capture and permanent storage, and one for CO2 capture and permanent storage without oil recovery. The Oil Sands Alliance project, which does not have an oil recovery component, falls under the latter CCS[1] quantification method. The result is unambiguous: the project sits entirely outside the gaseous credit market. The project’s compliance economics and the gaseous credit market are separate analyses.

Put simply: Despite the attention it has drawn, the Oil Sands Alliance carbon-capture project does not generate gaseous credits at all – it generates liquid ones. For anyone studying the gaseous market, this project is simply a separate conversation.

A separate but related development is the agreement between federal and Alberta authorities (s. 3.8) that a minimum 20% of Oil Sands Alliance CCS activity will be considered attributable to domestic fuel consumption and therefore eligible for CFR credit generation. This matters because CCS activity covers all crude production in Canada, but CFR credits can only be generated in respect of fuel consumed domestically. A guaranteed floor of 20% gives project developers a predictable minimum baseline for credit eligibility, which supports project financing. Those credits, however, are liquid CC1 credits. Participants evaluating CCS project economics in the context of CFR compliance should plan around liquid class credit generation and pricing, not around gaseous credit market dynamics.

Put simply: Governments have agreed that at least 20% of the project’s carbon-capture activity will count as tied to Canadian fuel use, giving developers a guaranteed minimum of credit-eligible activity to plan their financing around. But those credits are still liquid ones – so anyone modeling this project should be thinking about the liquid credit market, not the gaseous one.

The Practical Takeaway

The gaseous credit market under Canada’s CFR operates through mechanics that reward close attention. The eligible pathways for credit creation under s. 20 are narrower than they may appear; the 10% cap under s. 15(2) limits how much those credits can contribute to any single supplier’s obligation; and the most prominent CCS infrastructure project in Canada generates liquid CC1 credits, keeping it and the gaseous credit market on separate tracks. Participants who understand how each of these mechanics works are better positioned to evaluate supply opportunities, set realistic compliance strategies, and avoid overstating what the gaseous credit market can deliver.

Get expert insights on LCFS, CFP, BC-LCFS, and RFS credit prices.

Stillwater's Carbon Market Outlooks help fuels producers and investors cut through the noise, navigate carbon market uncertainty, and plan for the future.

[1]

The Oil Sands Alliance project appears in some federal documents under the acronym CCUS, which the Government of Canada expands as “Carbon Capture, Utilization and Storage.” The project proponent, the Oil Sands Alliance, uses CCS (carbon capture and storage) as its primary term. The distinction matters: CCUS implies a utilization component, meaning captured CO2 might be put to productive use before or instead of permanent storage. The project as designed has no such component; captured CO2 is compressed and permanently injected underground. CCS is the technically precise term. The federal government’s preference for CCUS reflects a broader policy umbrella rather than a description of the project’s actual design. This article uses CCS throughout.